No accountability.
They promise one thing to get elected, do another, and we wait four more years.
Promises on the public record, and what happened after the election. There is no federal recall vote between elections.
Electoral reform
The 2015 Liberal platform said 2015 would be the last federal election under first-past-the-post. It also said the plan would return Canada to a balanced budget in 2019.
Liberal Party of Canada, 2015 platformThe Speech from the Throne on 4 December 2015 repeated that 2015 would be the last federal election under first-past-the-post.
Speech from the Throne, 4 December 2015The special committee presented its electoral-reform report on 1 December 2016. The House voted the report down on 31 May 2017.
House of Commons, Special Committee on Electoral ReformOn 1 February 2017 the mandate letter said: “Changing the electoral system will not be in your mandate.”
Mandate letter, Minister of Democratic Institutions, 1 February 2017That day in the House, the minister said changing the electoral system was not in her mandate.
House of Commons Debates, 1 February 2017Elections Canada still describes the system as first-past-the-post. The candidate with the most votes wins, and an absolute majority is not required.
Elections Canada, Canada’s Political System
Other promises
On 23 April 1996 the Finance Minister quoted the 1993 Liberal promise to replace the GST, and said that day’s plan begins the process and does not complete it.
House of Commons Debates, 23 April 1996The GST is still 5%.
Excise Tax Act, section 165On 1 November 2006 the House heard the 2006 Conservative platform line: a Conservative government would preserve income trusts by not imposing any new taxes on them.
House of Commons Debates, 1 November 2006On 31 October 2006 the Finance Minister announced a tax on distributions from publicly traded income trusts.
Department of Finance, Tax Fairness Plan, 31 October 2006A 2007 law set the next election for 19 October 2009, unless Parliament was dissolved sooner.
An Act to amend the Canada Elections Act, S.C. 2007, c. 10Parliament was dissolved on 7 September 2008. The election was held on 14 October 2008.
Elections Canada, Report on the 40th General ElectionBudget 2019 projected a deficit of $19.8 billion for 2019–20.
Budget 2019, overview
Between elections
By October 2012, 65% of the 2011 Conservative platform promises were counted as kept in whole or in part. By March 2014 that share was over 80%.
Université Laval, POLTEXT, Harper Polimeter methodologyThe Canada Elections Act sets the date of the next general election. It does not let voters recall an MP.
Canada Elections Act, section 56.1
These are particular promises and later official records. They are not a score for every promise of every government.
Back to the home pageJoin UsAll evidence
Sources
- Liberal Party of Canada, 2015 platform
- Speech from the Throne, 4 December 2015
- House of Commons, Special Committee on Electoral Reform
- Mandate letter, Minister of Democratic Institutions, 1 February 2017
- House of Commons Debates, 1 February 2017
- Elections Canada, Canada’s Political System
- House of Commons Debates, 23 April 1996
- Excise Tax Act, section 165
- House of Commons Debates, 1 November 2006
- Department of Finance, Tax Fairness Plan, 31 October 2006
- An Act to amend the Canada Elections Act, S.C. 2007, c. 10
- Elections Canada, Report on the 40th General Election
- Budget 2019, overview
- Université Laval, POLTEXT, Harper Polimeter methodology
- Canada Elections Act, section 56.1